Replacing GNOME with mundaneDE

joe Linux will replace GNOME with mundaneDE, a desktop of its own under the BSD licence, and with applications made for it. GNOME stays the default until mundaneDE does everything the desktop does today.

joe Linux’s desktop is GNOME, laid out like Windows with four GNOME Shell extensions. It will be replaced by mundaneDE, a desktop that joe Linux develops itself, and by mundane-apps, a suite of applications written for it. Both are open source under the BSD 3-Clause licence, and both are public from today.

Nothing changes yet. GNOME stays the desktop of beta 2, and of every release until mundaneDE does everything the desktop does now. There are three reasons for the change.

A permissive licence for joe’s own desktop

joe Linux’s own code, dave and the installer among it, is under the MIT licence. Anyone may use it, change it and build on it, in free or in proprietary software, as long as they keep its copyright notice. The desktop is the largest part of joe Linux that joe Linux will write itself, and on GNOME it cannot follow that rule. GNOME’s window manager, mutter, and GNOME Shell are under the GPL. An extension is a derived work of GNOME Shell and must be distributed under compatible terms, which is why the four that make joe’s layout are GPL, and why anything joe Linux added to its desktop would be too.

mundaneDE is under the BSD 3-Clause licence, which asks little more than MIT does: keep the copyright notice, and do not use the authors’ names to promote what you make from it. Its compositor is built on Smithay (MIT), and its applications on GPUI, the interface toolkit of the Zed editor (Apache 2.0).

This is about the licence of what joe Linux writes, not of what it ships. The Linux kernel, GNU’s tools and GNOME’s applications are GPL software, and joe Linux will keep shipping them. Its security module is GPL too, as part of the kernel.

One system

dave is what makes joe Linux different: an upgrade is prepared while you work, applied to a snapshot as the machine shuts down, and undone by itself if the new system does not start. The GNOME desktop knows none of this. GNOME Software, which joe Linux offers for Flatpak applications, cannot manage dave’s packages, so installing one takes a terminal. Nothing on the desktop says that an upgrade is waiting for a restart, or that the machine went back to the system before.

mundaneDE and its applications are made for dave. The suite has a Packages application, a front end to dave: it searches, shows everything a change installs and removes before you confirm it, and tells an upgrade waiting for the restart apart from the system that is running. The desktop itself will say when an upgrade is waiting and when the machine went back. The shell, the settings and the applications share one design and are built and tested with the rest of joe Linux, instead of GNOME’s design with a layout added on top by extensions, each of which has to catch up with every GNOME release.

Still boring

joe Linux’s goal is to be as boring as possible for the person using it, and that does not change; mundaneDE has it in its name. The desktop keeps the layout it has now: a taskbar along the bottom with a start menu and tray icons, icons on the desktop, and windows with minimize and maximize buttons. What is new is meant to go unnoticed: a window dragged near an edge or another window settles against it, and animations can be reduced.

The change itself is made slowly:

  • mundaneDE comes first as a second choice on the login screen, next to GNOME.
  • It becomes the default only when it passes what the GNOME desktop passes now. make test-desktop starts every application of the desktop, with the security module logging and enforcing, and the same test will run on mundaneDE.
  • GNOME’s applications keep working on mundaneDE, and are replaced one at a time, each when its successor does the job.
  • The change of default will be announced here first, with what an upgrade does to an installed desktop.

Where it stands

mundaneDE is early. It runs in a window or on a single screen, moves windows on springs and snaps them into place, and shows a wallpaper; the shell, a lock screen and support for more than one screen are still to come. The applications start with a terminal, then Files, a text editor and a system monitor. The plans are in mundaneDE’s roadmap and mundane-apps’ plan.

All news